The Care Quality Commission is changing the method behind its care home ratings. Over 2026 it has consulted on, drafted and piloted a new assessment approach, and the changes are significant enough that families should understand what is — and is not — happening to the rating they see on a home’s profile.

This article summarises the CQC’s own published updates and the pilot timetable. It is an explainer, not a prediction: at the time of writing, the CQC had not published a confirmed date for the new framework to replace the current one at scale.

What is changing

The CQC currently uses a single assessment framework across the services it regulates. Following its “Better regulation, better care” consultation, it has developed four draft sector-specific assessment frameworks: adult social care, mental health care, primary care and community services, and hospitals (secondary and specialist care). The CQC said consultation feedback showed overwhelming support for moving away from a single framework (CQC, March 2026).

The draft frameworks keep the five key questions — safe, effective, caring, responsive and well-led — but change the material underneath them:

  • Key lines of enquiry framed as structured questions replace the current quality statements.
  • Rating characteristics describe what outstanding, good, requires improvement and inadequate care looks like in each sector.
  • Percentage scoring would be removed, with judgements made directly at key question level.

That last change matters to anyone who has compared a 72% “good” home with an 86% “good” home. Under the draft approach, the percentage would no longer be the summary measure; the judgement and its written reasons would carry more weight.

What is not changing — yet

The pilot did not replace normal inspections. The CQC ran the pilot alongside existing inspections between June and October 2026, with final evaluation planned for November 2026. Participation was voluntary, and the CQC is explicit that pilot judgements have no legal standing and do not affect regulatory status or rating (CQC, June 2026).

WhenWhat happened
Late 2025CQC consulted on proposals to evolve its assessment approach.
24 March 2026CQC published four draft sector-specific frameworks and opened feedback.
12 June 2026Feedback period on the draft frameworks closed.
June–October 2026Structured pilot and testing alongside existing inspections.
November 2026Final evaluation of the pilot planned.
After thatRefinement and a rollout at scale; timing not confirmed at the time of writing.
Sources: CQC March 2026 update; CQC piloting update, 4 June 2026.

Why the CQC is changing its approach

The single assessment framework was introduced in 2022 and has been criticised for being hard for providers and the public to follow, and for producing judgements that were difficult to explain. The CQC’s own consultation found support for frameworks that are more specific to each sector, and for rating characteristics that make clear what “good” looks like in context.

The pilots were also designed to test whether providers can clearly understand how ratings and judgements were reached — a direct response to concerns about transparency. That is a useful question for families too: a rating is only useful if you can see the evidence and reasoning behind it.

What it means if you are choosing a home now

Nothing about the pilot changes the rating you see today. The current ratings remain the CQC’s regulatory judgements, and the existing reports remain the evidence base. Use them as you would normally: check the inspection date, read the five key questions and look for enforcement action.

Two practical points are worth keeping in mind:

  • Check the date of the report. If a home was inspected under the current framework in 2025 or 2026, its rating reflects that framework. Future reports may look different even if the underlying care has not changed.
  • Ask about well-led. Leadership was the weakest key question in the CQC’s August 2026 care home data, and the new frameworks put more emphasis on clear rating characteristics. Ask the manager about governance, staff turnover and how concerns are escalated.

What to watch next

The CQC’s final evaluation, expected in November 2026, should say what it learned from the pilots and what it will change before rollout. After that, look for a published implementation timeline, updated guidance for providers, and the first reports written under the new approach. We will update this article when the CQC confirms those details.